Okay, so I finally decided to give this whole butt plug thing a try. I’ve heard about it, seen it, been curious, but never actually done it. So, this is my journey, from start to finish, of wearing a butt plug for the first time, and figuring out how long I could actually keep it in.

Prepping for the Plug
First things first, I needed a plug. I did a little browsing, decided to pick a small, silicone one – seemed like the safest bet for a beginner. And, obviously, lube. Lots and lots of lube. Don’t skimp on the lube, people. Trust me.
I made sure I was, uh, cleansed. You know, took care of business beforehand. Showered, felt fresh, all that good stuff. It’s all about setting the mood, right? Making it a comfortable experience.
The Insertion
Okay, deep breaths. I got myself comfortable, lying on my side. Plenty of lube on the plug, plenty on myself. Slow and steady wins the race, as they say. I started with just the tip, wiggled it a bit, then gently pushed it in. It felt… weird. Not painful, just… different. A new sensation, for sure.
Took a few more breaths, pushed it in a little further. It definitely took some getting used to. The feeling of fullness was… intense. I wasn’t sure I liked it at first. But I kept going, slow and steady, until the whole thing was in. The base was sitting comfortably against me, which felt reassuring.
The Waiting Game
Now came the “how long” part. I decided to start with a short time, just to see how it felt. I set a timer for 30 minutes. Walked around a bit, did some chores. It was definitely noticeable. I could feel it there the whole time, a constant pressure. It wasn’t uncomfortable, but it wasn’t exactly ignorable either.

- 30 Minutes In: Feeling okay. A little pressure, but nothing major. Decided to keep going.
- 1 Hour In: Still okay. Started to get used to the feeling. It’s kind of… interesting. I can see why people get into this.
- 2 Hours In: Okay, starting to feel a little… antsy. Like I need to, you know, go. But I’m determined to push it a bit longer.
- 2 Hours 30 Minutes In: I called time to remove.
The Removal
Getting it out was… easier than getting it in, that’s for sure. A little more lube, a gentle tug, and it popped right out. Relief! But also… a weird sense of emptiness? It’s hard to explain.
The Aftermath
I definitely felt a bit… different afterwards. Like my muscles were a little tired, or maybe just relaxed. Nothing painful, just… aware of that area, if you know what I mean.
So, my first time? A success, I guess! I managed two and a half hours. Not sure if that’s good or bad, but it felt like a good starting point for me. Will I do it again? Maybe. It was definitely an experience, and I’m not opposed to exploring it further. But for now, I’m good. I’ve learned my limit, at least for the first try!