Getting Started with a New Toy
Okay, so folks ask sometimes, what’s the deal with butt plugs? What do they actually feel like? I figured I’d share my own little journey with trying one out. It wasn’t some big dramatic thing, more like curiosity finally won out, you know?

First off, picking one. I went for something small and smooth, silicone mostly. Nothing intimidating. Figured starting small was the smart play. Got some good quality lube too – seriously, don’t skip this step. Learned that the easy way, thankfully.
The Actual Experience
So, time came to actually try it. Found a relaxed moment, got comfy. Applying the lube was step one, plenty of it, both on the plug and, well, you know where it’s going. Taking a deep breath, I went slow. Really slow.
The initial feeling? It’s kinda weird, not gonna lie. A distinct pressure, like something’s there that isn’t normally. Not painful, more… surprising? It’s a muscle down there you don’t often pay attention to, and suddenly it’s very aware of this new object.
Once it was fully in, the feeling changed a bit. It settled into this sense of fullness. It’s hard to describe perfectly. Think about wearing a ring that’s slightly too tight, but inside? Not uncomfortable, just constantly noticeable. A low-level hum of sensation.
- Pressure: Definitely the main thing. A constant, gentle pressure from within.
- Fullness: A feeling of being occupied, filled.
- Awareness: You become very aware of that part of your body.
I decided to just chill for a bit first, lying down. Then I tried walking around the room. That changed things slightly. The pressure felt like it shifted with movement. Again, not bad, just different. It made me walk a little more deliberately, I guess.

Kept it in for maybe 20 minutes the first time. Didn’t want to push it. The feeling didn’t really intensify, just stayed consistent. A constant reminder it was there.
Taking it Out and Final Thoughts
Removal was pretty straightforward. Slow and steady, just like insertion. There was a slight release of pressure, and then… back to normal. Felt surprisingly empty afterwards for a second, which was funny.
So, what does it feel like? For me, it was mainly about pressure and a unique sense of fullness. It wasn’t overwhelming or instantly mind-blowing, more of a subtle, constant internal sensation. It’s definitely a unique feeling, different from other kinds of touch or toys. Worth trying if you’re curious, but like anything, go slow, use lube, and listen to your body. That was my experience, anyway.