Alright, so I had this idea stuck in my head for a while – you know that saying, “have her cake and eat it too”? Well, I wanted to see if I could actually make that happen, literally. Not some deep philosophical thing, just a straight-up baking experiment. My thought was, why not try to create a single cake you can just keep, and just take a slice whenever you want and still have the cake?

So, first I grabbed a bunch of recipes. I looked through tons of my grandma’s old cookbooks and browsed through the cooking website to find something that looked like it would work for what I wanted to do. I wanted something that would hold its shape, but not be dry as a desert after a day or two. I finally settled on a dense pound cake recipe. Seemed sturdy enough.
Next, I got all my ingredients together. Flour, sugar, eggs, butter, the usual suspects. I even splurged on some fancy vanilla extract, because why not? This was an important project, after all.
Mixing was the fun part. I creamed the butter and sugar until it was nice and fluffy, then cracked in the eggs one by one, mixing well after each addition. Slowly, I added the dry ingredients, being careful not to overmix. Overmixing is a big no-no, my grandma always said.
Now for the tricky part. I needed two cake pans, one slightly smaller than the other. I greased and floured both of them, then poured most of the batter into the larger pan. In the smaller pan, I only poured a thin layer, maybe an inch or so. The idea was to bake a small, flat cake that I could use as a “replacement” slice later.
I popped them both in the oven and waited. The smaller one was done pretty quickly, but the bigger one took a while. I kept checking it with a toothpick until it came out clean. Perfect.

Once they were both cooled, I carefully removed the larger cake from its pan. Then, I sliced a piece out, just like you normally would. I took the smaller, flat cake and trimmed it to roughly match the size of the missing slice. With a bit of frosting as “glue”, I stuck the replacement slice into the gap.
The results?
- Looks: From a distance, it actually looked like a whole cake again. Up close, you could see the seams, but it wasn’t too bad.
- Taste: The pound cake was delicious, as expected. And the “replacement” slice tasted just the same. I just enjoy my slice of cake.
- “Having it”: I still had a cake, though not perfectly, with a replacement slice. I could keep the cake for a few more days and try it again.
So, yeah, it worked, kind of. It’s not exactly the same as the saying, but it was a fun experiment. I got to enjoy my cake and still look at a full cake, which it is a nice experiment. I’m thinking about trying it again with different types of cake, maybe chocolate next time. Who knows, maybe I’ll perfect this whole “have your cake and eat it too” thing yet!